The publication process
What happens to a manuscript from submission to publication. The steps are the same in every Palmyra journal.
- Submission. You submit through the journal's submission system and receive an automatic acknowledgement.
- Editorial check. The editorial office checks scope, completeness, ethical declarations and similarity. Manuscripts that fail the check are returned without review, with the reason.
- Double-anonymised peer review by at least two independent reviewers. Neither side learns the other's identity.
- Decision: accept, revise, or decline, sent with the reviewers' reports.
- Revision. You revise and explain each change in a response letter; the editor may consult the reviewers again.
- Acceptance and production: copyediting, typesetting and proofs, which you check and approve.
- Publication. The article is published in the current issue, free to read, under CC BY 4.0. Articles may appear under Early publication before their issue is complete.
Current status. No Palmyra journal is open to submissions yet. Each journal opens only when the conditions for opening a journal are met, starting with the appointment of its Editor-in-Chief. Each journal's home page shows whether it is accepting submissions.
Who is responsible at each step
| Step | Responsible | What the author receives |
|---|---|---|
| Submission | The journal's submission system | An automatic acknowledgement by e-mail |
| Editorial check | The editorial office checks completeness, anonymisation, declarations and similarity; the handling editor then checks scope and readiness | Either notice that the manuscript has gone to review, or a decision with the reasons |
| Peer review | The handling editor (an associate editor) invites the reviewers and follows up late reports; the editorial office sends the reminders | Nothing until the decision; reviewers are never named |
| Decision | The Editor-in-Chief, or an associate editor to whom the decision has been delegated. Never the publisher | The decision letter with the reviewers' reports |
| Revision | The author, then the handling editor | A further decision; revised work may go back to the reviewers |
| Production | The editorial office: copyediting, typesetting and metadata | Proofs to check and approve |
| After publication | The editors and the publisher, following COPE guidance on corrections and retractions | A permanent public record; nothing published is silently changed or removed |
Every decision, letter and review is recorded in the journal's submission system. Complaints and appeals are handled as set out in the editorial policies.
Timing
Review times depend on reviewers' availability and are not guaranteed. The journals make no promise of rapid acceptance, and no payment or favour speeds a manuscript up. Reviewers are asked to reply to an invitation within one week and to report within three weeks, and they receive automatic reminders.
Related pages
- Preparing your manuscript, with a checklist
- Editorial review process and complaints and appeals
- Promoting your article after publication